Connect with us

Headlines

Hill’s Accused of ‘Coordinated Scheme’ to Convince Consumers That Grain-Free Pet Food Increases Risk of DCM

The case was filed on behalf of KetoNatural Pet Foods, a Utah-based pet food startup that manufactures low-carbohydrate dog food products

mm

Published

on

A lawsuit filed against Hill’s Pet Nutrition Inc. and other defendants alleges that they “carried out a coordinated scheme to persuade American pet-owners that the grain-free dog food products sold by many Hill’s competitors all increase the risk and severity of a deadly canine heart disease called dilated cardiomyopathy,” according to a news release.

The case was filed on behalf of KetoNatural Pet Foods, a Utah-based pet food startup that manufactures low-carbohydrate dog food products. “The suit alleges that KetoNatural is one of the many smaller pet food brands that were damaged by the false ‘association’ between its products and DCM,” according to a press release from Wolf Haldenstein Adler Freeman & Herz LLP, which filed the proposed class-action litigation.

Reuters reported that KetoNatural “is seeking class-action status for at least several hundred companies.” The $2.6 billion in damages sought would be the largest in the history of the U.S. pet food industry, said Thomas Burt, partner with Wolf Haldenstein.

In addition to Hill’s, which is a subsidiary of Colgate-Palmolive Co., defendants include “a group of academic veterinarians and organizations with financial ties to the company,” according to the release from Wolf Haldenstein. Named in the suit are Hill’s, the Morris Animal Foundation, the Mark Morris Institute and five veterinarians. Colgate-Palmolive has not yet responded publicly to the suit, according to Reuters. We will update this story as we learn more.

The suit, KetoNatural Pet Foods v. Hill’s Pet Nutrition, was filed in the U.S. District Court for the District of Kansas on Feb. 6.

More from the release:

The scheme allegedly involved a wide range of malfeasance committed by the defendants, most notably fraudulently misrepresenting case data about DCM to the United States Food and Drug Administration (“FDA”). The FDA spent more than five years conducting a widely publicized investigation into “a potential association” between grain-free dog foods and DCM, only to suspend further investigation updates last year after announcing that it had not found sufficient data to establish a relationship between DCM and the products under investigation.

The suit alleges that the FDA’s DCM investigation was fraudulently induced by Hill’s-affiliated veterinarians at Tufts University and other major research institutions, all of which have received extensive funding from Hill’s-affiliated entities. The veterinarians allegedly caused the FDA to take drastic action by flooding the agency with hundreds of DCM case reports that were intentionally chosen to overrepresent the commonality of grain-free diets among dogs suffering from the disease.

The FDA’s investigation received major media coverage in 2018 and 2019, sparking a panic over DCM that caused the market for grain-free pet foods to drop by billions of dollars. The suit alleges that Hill’s and its co-conspirators then stoked the panic by making false statements about the scientific evidence surrounding DCM, both to the veterinary community and the general public, as well as by manipulating the language of academic papers, using front organizations to hide undisclosed payments to veterinary researchers, and creating Facebook groups and websites to amplify misinformation and suppress dissent.

According to the lawsuit, this scheme produced a shocking financial windfall for Hill’s, a company that had been steadily losing market share to grain-free competitors in the years preceding the controversy:

In the four years immediately preceding the launch of the FDA’s investigation, Hill’s lost 20% of its market share. In the five years since the investigation began it has been arguably the fastest growing pet food company in the country.

The case was filed on behalf of KetoNatural Pet Foods, a Utah-based petfood startup that specializes in manufacturing low-carbohydrate dog food products. The suit alleges that KetoNatural is one of the many smaller pet food brands that were damaged by the false “association” between its products and DCM. Evidence submitted as part of the new suit shows that many KetoNatural customers stopped feeding the company’s products to their dogs after being told by veterinarians that the products had been shown to raise the risk of canine DCM.

According to Mr. Burt, pet food brands such as KetoNatural are just one of several discrete groups that have been harmed by Hill’s and its co-conspirators. “We know that boutique pet food retailers and pet-owners around the country were also damaged by the false idea that grain-free pet foods increase the risk of canine DCM. As we continue to investigate potential claims against Hill’s and its co-conspirators, we urge anyone who believes they have been harmed by the misconduct described in this suit to contact our offices.”

Source: Wolf Haldenstein Adler Freeman & Herz LLP

Contact: burt@whafh.com

About Wolf Haldenstein:

Founded in 1888, Wolf Haldenstein is among the nation’s leading firms representing consumers, investors and small businesses in consumer protection, antitrust, and securities litigation. For more information, please visit www.whafh.com.

About KetoNatural Pet Foods:

KetoNatural Pet Foods makes foods, treats, and supplements for companion animals, including Ketona, a line of dry dog food products with 90% less dietary carbohydrate and twice as much meat-based protein as foods produced by “traditional” pet food brands. The company was founded by Daniel Schulof, activist and author of the 2016 book Dogs, Dog Food, and Dogma, which has been called “the most rigorous and probing canine nutrition book ever written.” For more information, please visit www.ketonaturalpetfoods.com.

Advertisement

Most Popular

xx1toto pucuk4d buah4d mposlot mpo1221 menara188 lunatogel lunatogel lunatogel-togelup.hayatesabz.net lunatogel gebyar4d lazawin https://arabiplus.ir seributoto timnas4d asian4d terminal4d KEY4D linitoto lunatogel lunatogel surgaplay wis77 kaisar poker xx1toto hw77bet xx1toto lunatogel garuda4d mamibet timnas4d garuda4d garuda4d latoto prada4d GARUDA4D TERMINAL4D terminalbet terminal4d ollo4d batik77 MERAHTOTO a200m balak66 supraslot f200m SKY77 asia77 aman788 sgi88 ajaib88 TIMNAS4D ASIAN4D KEBAYA4D TIMNAS4D ASIA77 garuda4d barbar77 PRADA4D ayo788 langit69 GEBYAR4D terminalbet balak66 garuda4d unsurtoto gebyar4d prediksi77 key4d asian4d kaisarpoker depo89 PAJAKTOTO PAJAKTOTO PGBET aman788 davo88 rans303 ayo788 OLLO4D OLLO4D garuda4d lapak7d WAJIK777 fuji388 TIMNAS4D F200M kaisarpoker kaisarpoker kaisarpoker SUGAR RUSH 1000 OLLO4D aman788 KAISARPOKER TIMNAS4D TIMNAS4D garuda4d scatter hitam KILAT77 lunatogel sontogel haotogel OLLO4D linitoto timnas4d asian4d ollo4d MERIAH4D megahoki TERMINAL4D key4d inatogel depo89 mamibet davo88 batik77 cocol88 okta188 key4d pajaktoto ASIA77 TIMNAS4D KEY4D LAPAK7D PAJAKTOTO udin88 KAISARPOKER wdbos ollo4d gacor77 timnas4d KILAT77 ganas33 KEY4D tiktaktogel https://hayatesabz.net pajaktoto xx1toto TERMINAL4D oppatoto lunatogel key4d kaisarpoker situstoto PALU4D PG SOFT GARUDA4D WDBOS ASIA77 OLLO4D asian4d pgbet situstoto SURGA5000 PROBET88 kilat77 lunatogel asian4d monperatoto TERMINAL4D situs toto linkgacor.situsmaxwin asia77 clinicaspararecuperacao.com.br envystudiogt.com inspire-breathwork.squarespace.com hotelearthlight.com hexagonview.com sky77 TERMINAL4D ANGKASA168 satorirattan.com TERMINAL4D LAPAK7D key4d slot qris dapurtoto JURANGAN69 timnas4d GARUDA4D WAJIK777 PRADA188 garuda4d asia77 SKY77 terminal4d gila138 KAISARPOKER TERMINAL4D ASIAN4D KEY4D meriah4d SKY77 PAJAKTOTO ollo4d pajaktoto GARUDA4D TERMINAL4D LAPAK7D MERIAH4D ollo4d sky77 angsa4d key4d kaisarpoker timnas4d kaisarpoker kaisarpoker TIMNAS4D timnas4d terminal4d KAISARPOKER garuda4d daytonamasala.com PADMA88 sky77 sgcwin88 TERMINAL4D garuda4d satorirattan.co.id KILAT77 ollo4d lion4d key4d titi4d POS4D pajaktoto POS4D LAPAK7D pajaktoto OLLO4D PAJAKTOTO GBOTOTO https://lexcliq.com clinicaspararecuperacao.com.br hayatesabz.ir/ shopeeindonesia.co.id KILAU4D SPRING.COM hayatesabz.net centralfinance.com.np timnas4d rskasihherlinatimika.com parininihi.co.nz emasan.desa.id almanahmamiregi.sch.id timnas4d sggswu.edu.in/ terminal4d NUSABET88 debredamohotel.com SKY77 TERMINAL4D mialamanah.sch.id thanhlongsf.com KEY4D PAJAKTOTO TERMINAL4D techkritigroup.com radarnasional.net situsgacorxx1toto xx1toto linkgacorxx1toto xx1toto lexcliq.com lexcliq.com asian4d HW77BET TERMINAL4D HW77BET PAJAKTOTO HW77BET HW77BET HW77BET HW77BET pg soft xx1toto TERMINAL4D mahjong69 TERMINAL4D asian4d kaisarpoker tokekwin WAJIK777 MARETTOTO tiktaktogel astonbet hw77bet/ TOKYO88/ kenzototo sangathoki siji4d papuwa4d brri4d megagacor key4d f200m xx1toto KILAU4D KAMPUS88 WD138 AZTEC88 timnas4d GEBYAR4D NIRWANA88 ohtogel slot88 HW77BET sangathoki TERMINAL4D kenzototo omtogel situsmaxwin merahtoto TERMINAL4D xx1toto pusat4d kenzototo sangathoki https://gacorslot7d.com/ TANCAP88 https://linkgacor.ratteb.com/ Situs Togel | Bandar Togel Online 2024 Situs TUS4D Situs Toto Aceh4d xx1totok terminal4d hw77slot TERMINAL4D KODE4D SUPRASLOT gila138 kilat77 xx1toto davo88 mpo2121 domtoto lunatogel jonitogel JET77 coloksgp sbctoto wongtoto okta388 hantogel suletoto topjitu win88 xx1toto juragan69 cuan123 rans303 lapak7d kaisarpoker latoto hades88 latoto MEGA338 aquaslot xx1toto papuwa4d siji4d Situs Toto Link Aceh4d fendi188 arjuna96 j200m lunatogel slot gacor tus4d aceh4d Pandora88 LAPAK7D Login Aceh4d bigwin138 mantra88 tustoto mio777 mainaja TOKYO88 koin138 TERMINAL4D LAPAK7D situspentaslot Tus4D KAISARPOKER TERMINAL4D dewihoki Link Aceh4d Tus4D Aceh4d WASIAT4D terminal4d epicwin138 BUAYA138 kaisarpoker nasa4d superdavo88 lapak7d maha168 kilat77 ANGKA69 dewa88 ollo4d grandbet88 KAISARPOKER TERMINAL4D PARIS77 AIRBET88 bakar77 surga88 kacang99 kaisarpoker dewa33 asiahoki bos88 88big EMAS168 lapak7d KAISARPOKER cocol88 garuda4d vava4d moba4d terminal4d kaisarpoker timnas4d langit69 bosswin168 terminal4d 88mega KING138 COCOL88 PAJAKTOTO kaisarpoker fendi188 CIPIT88 terminal4d kenzototo terminal4d bingo4d mega188 LAPAK7D DRAGON4D live toto macau TIMNAS4D terminal4d maxwin89 ANGSA4D GEBYAR4D SURGA88 TIMNAS4D MAXWIN138 terminal4d sakti123 tunas4d LAPAK7D DEPOSIT TANPA ANTRIAN agen77 dragon4d TERMINAL4D catur777 GBOWIN mamibet PALU4D ANGSA4D slot777 terminal4d dragon4d bro138 POCARI4D LUNATOGEL HOKI777 kilau4d POCARI4D UDINTOGEL HOMETOGEL TIMNAS4D LAPAK7D sky77 SBCTOTO kaisarpoker sandibet LAPAK7D BENTO123 PRADA188 LAPAK7D sawer4d BACKLINK
https://www.tugumandiri.com/udintogel/
KAISARPOKER TERMINAL4D kaisarpoker JNT777 TERMINAL4D PRADA4D madetoto batik77 KAISARPOKER lapak7d TERMINAL4D RAJA328 SENOPATI4D pedangwin SGCWIN lazawin MAXWIN138 KAISARPOKER meriah4d TERMINAL4D terminal4d SLOT5000 SISIL4D harta138 MAXWIN138 DRAGON4D lapak7d harum4d MOLE4D kpktoto KAISARPOKER neng4d PUSAT4D megawin188 TERMINAL4D sgcwin rasa4d bimabet lapak7d Acehflix21 Nonton Film Gratis kangtoto kilat77 Lapak7d KAISARPOKER LAPAK7D Terminal4d Terminal4d bacan4d bacan4d kaisarpoker lapak7d pocari4d bacan4d bacansport lapak7d terminal4d bacansport raja328 cermat88 XX1TOTO >> LINK ALTERNATIF SLOT GACOR AMAN DAN TERPERCAYA manjurbet Daftar situs slot online bacan4d lapak7d terminal4d Lapak7d LAPAK7D terminal4d BOBATOTO kaisarpoker xx1toto hw77slot terminal4d sgcwin88 mpxtoto pocari4d XX1TOTO >> Link Slot Gacor Server Luar Pasti Menang Auto Maxwin hwslot77 MATAHARI88 DAFTAR SITUS JUDI TOGEL ONLINE 2023 SLOTALADIN DEDE4D : DAFTAR SITUS JUDI TOGEL DAN SLOT ONLINE DAFTAR MPXTOTO SITUS SLOT THAILAND PALING GACOR PAUS138 >> Situs Nomor 1 Slot Gacor Hari Ini Pasti Menang Aman Terpercaya LINK ALTERNATIF MEGA188 DAFTAR DAN LOGIN MEGA138 XX1TOTO | Rekomendasi Link Situs Slot Pasti Menang Setiap Player Ada Jatah Maxwin Tikus4d | Situs Slot Online Gacor Terbaik Pasti Menang 2023 NEOTOTO lapak7d LINK SLOT GACOR BOS138 DAFTAR SITUS TOGEL ONLINE CIPUTRA88 LINK ALTERNATIF TITI4D PISTOL4D SLOT GACOR >> LINK AKTIF SITUS SLOT GACOR RTP 98% AMAN TERPERCAYA bacan4d shio togel 2024 TWSLIVE - Situs Aman Terpercaya x500 Sering Muncul Auto Maxwin XX1TOTO GARUDA138 DAFTAR DAN LOGIN neototo KAMPUS88 | Situs Resmi Casino Slot Gacor pasti Menang Terpercaya Gacor77 LINK ALTERNATIF GACOR77 winstar4d GILa138 - Zeus4d Situs Slot Online lagi gacor pgsoft deposit murah bonus gede GELAY88 > Jitu77 Agen Slot Pragmatic Online Terpercaya Deposit Gampang Menang TITI4d - Situs Togel Slot Perkalian X500 Sering Keluar Pasti Bayar Aman Terpercaya Slot88 GARUDA138 SITUS SLOT GACOR DAFTAR SITUS SLOT ONLINE GARUDA138 NEOTOTO SLOT PASTI MAXWIN >> LINK SITUS GACOR PRAGMATIC DAN PG SOFT PASTI MENANG ADA JATAH MAXWIN OLXTOTO PAKDE4D >> BO TOGEL ONLINE SLOT PRAGMATIC CASINO DI INDONESIA AMAN TERPERCAYA PASTI BAYAR XX1TOTO PG SOFT - WAJIB MENANG AUTO MAXWIN DENGAN PROVIDER RNG TERBAIK XX1TOTO SLOT PGSOFT - PROVIDER TERBAIK DENGAN RNG BERKUALITAS TINGGI AMAN TERPERCAYA XX1TOTO PRAGMATIC PLAY | SITUS SLOT RNG TINGKAT TINGGI TANPA MANIPULASI AMAN TERPERCAYA SLOT88 XX1TOTO Sweet Bonanza >> Play77 Provider Terbaik dan Resmi Slot Bonanza Aman Terpercaya XX1TOTO Slot Starlight Princess | Situs Gacor Resmi Pragmatic Play RNG Sistem Permainan Adil

neototo

XX1TOTO SERVER THAILAND | SITUS SLOT SERVER LUAR NO 1 PALING DICARI DI INDONESIA XX1TOTO SERVER THAILAND >> SITUS GACOR SERVER LUAR NO.1 PALING DICARI AMAN DAN TERPERCAYA XX1TOTO SERVER RUSIA | SITUS GACOR SERVER LUAR RNG PERMAINAN ADIL AMAN DAN TERPERCAYA NEOTOTO XX1TOTO SERVER DUBAI >> JITU77 SERVER LUAR PALING GACOR AMAN DAN TERPERCAYA LINK ALTERNATIF XX1TOTO | LINK ANTI NAWALA TERBARU TANPA VPN 2023 PALING GACOR AMAN DAN TERPERCAYA XX1TOTO | CHEAT ENGINE SLOT ONLINE PASTI MENANG JACKPOT CARA PAKAI GAMPANG HW77SLOT | SITUS GACOR AMAN TERPERCAYA NO.1 DI INDONESIA TANPA VPN MAXWIN138 DAFTAR DAN LOGIN LINK ALTERNATIF GAME JUDI ONLINE GACOR77 LUXURY333 | LINK ANTI BLOKIR GAME JUDI ONLINE TERPERCAYA XX1TOTO xx1toto Login TERMINAL4D | Situs Gacor TERMINAL4D | DAFTAR TERMINAL4D | LINK TERMINAL4D | LINK ANTI NAWALA TERMINAL4D TERMINAL4D - LINK AKTIF ANTI NAWALA T4D 2023 AMAN DAN TERPERCAYA Bacan4d Bacansports Bacan4d Bacan4d Bacan4d Kaisar21 dingdongtogel hometogel jeboltogel pocari4d evostoto koitoto oreo5d olxtoto xx1toto hw77bet hw77bet JEJUSLOT warung168 winter4d hw77bet macan33 pasarbet168 fit188 jkt77 harum4d 29hoki obs188 jp188 area188 bento123 LINK RESMI KAMPUS88 kampus88 tumi123 gasing777 semutwin batman138 kangtotovip mw68 musangwin dewa212vip beta138slot sinarjpslot rajahoki899slot dragon78 kangtotogames airbet88 supraslot ohtogel kangtoto demo bacansports mame123 login & daftar ibet44 > Situs Bandar Slot Dan bola Terkini MASTER38 >> Link Situs Alternatif Login Dan Daftar Slot Online DAGET77 >> Link Login Dan Daftar Slot Online Ibet44 >> Link Login Alternatif Anti Nawala sawit188 Api5000 Link Slot Gacor ajr88 Baron69 buntogel davo88 murah4d angsa4d ohtogel togelup togelon epicwin138 batmantoto merdeka138 slot88 nagawon mamibet omtogel nasa4d pahlawan4d wongtoto xx1toto latoto inatogel kenzototo merdeka138 lionbola japan168 megawin188 mega288 kenzototo winstar88 coktogel key4d bosswin168 net77 pin4d zora4d latoto hw77slot gameonline xx1toto slotgacor cuan77 merdeka777 surgawin TUS4D LINK LOGIN & DAFTAR koitoto pamanslot mentoz4d mustang303 plaza4d2 suara4d bar88 bali777 rajahoki899 surgawin bacansports gurita4d dewi188 winlive4d kebaya4d /murah4d plaza4d2 xx1toto neko4d sabi4d cermat88 sabi4d hw77bet nyonya4d kitab4d birutoto beta138 BIRUTOTO aye4d PROTOGEL xx1toto bulantogel togelup idcash88 imbaslot wsdbola88 mabosway klix4d maxwin138 rtp luxury333 sis4d tanta88 ayam4d benua99 xx1toto benua99 musangwin bacansportsgames nagawon piramidslot batikslot game online slot slotgacor mawar189 boss177 era77 kebaya4d kebaya4d zona69 venus4d spinhoki88 angkasajp kas77 hurajp mahjong69 ronin86 besti69 prediksi77 XX1Movie Flazzmovie video muncrat Banyak cerita 99 xx1toto hw77bet hw77bet terminal4d hw77bet xx1toto.com rajabandot hw77bet xx1slot surga5000 akartoto platinumtoto rajawalitoto xx1toto xx1toto togelon pohon4d chutogel skintoto jambitoto prabujitu xx1toto xx1toto xx1toto panen77 kampung138 bom338 interwin bacan4d slot234 keris77 curhat338 mposlot bom338 interwin interwin demo bacansports jawara88 menang123 mainaja dokter88 nobar69 pom77 kuy4d bonanza88 sultan33 sihoki rajasloto grandbet88 inatogel jet77 yoktogel xx1slot koko303 kode4d hw77bet xx1toto xx1toto mantra88 captogel kompastoto polototo suster4d akartoto jabartoto prada188 koko303 jostoto yotogel totojitu xx1toto sbctoto togelup merahtoto slot88 latoto dot77 qqmacan bacan4d bacansport acehbola lapak7d terminal4d kaisarpoker xx1toto hw77bet neototo slot mahjong slot zeus 1000 onic77 mechaslot ratu555 bso88 bursa33 cukongbet lgo66 media77 rrq88 qqhok tus4d tus4d subur88 sawer138 rupiah168 lotusbet88 uya4d musang88 squad777 pancing77 imbabet albino4d epicwin138 bacan4d toto macau grandbet88 titanbet303 agen338 inatogel tentoto xx1toto xx1toto xx1toto togelon togelup tentoto inatogel hw77bet hw77bet minitoto oppatoto sabi4d kangtoto laetoto mariatogel linitoto sritoto unsurtoto tstoto kantortoto popotogel togelon winjitu manadototo xx1toto mariatogel lunatogel bulantogel manadototo wolestogel perkasajitu jualtoto cocol88 airbet88 minitoto oppatoto medantoto mawartoto hotogel rajasloto zorototo link mahkotajitu online pulitoto spvtoto thailand bantogel pisang123 terminal4d key4d asustogel aseptogel xx1toto nirwana88 ngawitoto chutogel nuansa4d angkasajp kacang99 kepritogel kepritogel kantortoto sbctoto lampiontogel sbctoto xx1toto xx1toto xx1toto xx1toto xx1toto xx1toto xx1toto bobatoto ungu508 pisang123 pg138 bacansports slot thailand sop88 soda69 kuybet pbototo tokek88 aceh4d slot mahjong bacansports bacansports bacansports rakatoto dewi188 lunatogel kilat77 mono77 rajabandot manadototo skintoto neng4d Bacan4d bacansports Wla188 katakwin kota189 maujp nagawon pundi188 satset138 wing138 wisnu123 rekor11 bo177 hit77 legowin777 mabar69